I can’t believe this really happened. Are you sure there isn’t a special 17th game this year? I know everyone else in the NFL does. The fact that a team was able to accomplish another undefeated regular season isn’t entirely astonishing. Basic stats will tell you that eventually someone was bound to do it, but not in this “new era” of free agency. The rules were supposed to ensure that dynasties would be rare, let alone the thought of an undefeated season.
These facts ensure that the 2007 New England Patriots belong right in the discussion with the 1972 Dolphins and 1985 Bears as the best teams in football history. I’m sure people who read this will wax poetic about the 1970s Steelers and the 1989 49ers and maybe even Cowboys of the early 1990s. Heck, someone can throw an argument about the old, old, old, old, old-school Browns or Bears in the mix. I’ll gladly throw all those teams right back in your face.
First of all, let’s eliminate any teams prior to the first Super Bowl. Basic rule, if there’s more than one league declaring its team champions, then there’s no real champion unless they actually play one another (hope the NCAA is listening). That brings us to the first real dynasty, the Green Bay Packers, talented yes, coached by one of the best ever, but not overwhelming by any means.
Now we move into the 1970s where the Dolphins won their perfect season, but the Steelers ruled the decade. Perfect reasoning why they don’t belong in the discussion. They set a standard for long-term excellence, but can you really distinguish the 1975 team, from the 1976 team, or the 1978 team? Me neither. Which brings us to the 1989 49ers. A team built with parts very similar to this year’s Patriots (Montana/Brady, Rice/Moss), but also a team that finished 11-5, not overly impressive despite their blowout win in the Super Bowl. If you can’t even go 13-3, you don’t belong in the “best team” discussion.
As for the 1990s Cowboys, you could use the same argument as the Steelers. Their best finish was 13-3. Anyone wanna take a guess what this year’s Cowboys team finished at? That’s right, 13-3. Know who beat the 13-3 Cowboys by more than 20? That’s right, the Patriots. I think my point’s been made.
This leaves us with three teams in the circle, the ‘72 Dolphins, the ‘85 Bears and the ‘07 Pats. Granted, it’s difficult to truly compare the Dolphins and the Patriots because the players today are so much bigger. But based on their weak schedule of that season, their nailbiters in the playoffs and the fact that the season itself was shorter, I have to put the Dolphins third. Call it futuristic bias, but that’s just the way it works.
As for the Bears, I have a friends who is a Chicago Superfan like the guys in the SNL skit, he adores anything Windy City and probably has a shrine to the great Ditka in his room. Even he admitted after the Ravens victory that New England would run the table and surpass his beloved Bears as the greatest team in history. However, to show that I have the ability to reason, I’ll hold that title for now. Should the Pats survive what appears to be a terrible gauntlet of a playoff road and win the Super Bowl, you have to give it to them. No team’s ever gone 19-0, until then it’s Bears 1, Pats 2. Hey, at least it’s closer than the ‘86 Super Bowl.